Why You Shouldn't Make Big Decisions While Grieving (And What to Do Instead)
Grief clouds judgment and decision-making. Learn why major choices should wait and how to handle decisions you cannot avoid during bereavement.
Key Takeaways
- Grief significantly impairs cognitive function and decision-making capacity for months, making major choices potentially harmful to your future
- Your brain temporarily rewires itself during grief, suppressing reasoning centers while amplifying emotional responses to help you survive trauma
- Memorial and end-of-life decisions can often be delayed without consequence, allowing cognitive clarity to return naturally over time
- When decisions cannot wait, structured frameworks and trusted advisors can protect you from choices you might later regret
- Recovery timelines vary greatly, but most people see improvement in thinking clarity between 6-18 months after loss
Reflections on love, loss and the ways we carry them.
If decision-making feels impossible right now, I want to say this plainly: there is nothing wrong with you. What you’re experiencing is grief doing exactly what it does to every human brain. Loss doesn’t just break the heart. It temporarily rewires how we think, remember, and choose. When concentration slips and confidence disappears, it isn’t weakness. It’s protection.
In early bereavement, the brain shifts into survival mode. The part responsible for planning and weighing consequences quiets down, while the emotional centers take over. This is why even simple decisions can feel heavy, and permanent ones, especially those tied to memory and meaning—can feel unbearable. We are often asked to “decide” before our minds are ready to hold clarity again.
One client, Chris from Illinois, shared that after his mother’s death, he felt paralyzed by choices she had never put into words. When a memorial option was finally presented, not urgently, not insistently, he described it as “a weight lifted,” not because he had decided quickly, but because he was allowed time.
That permission matters. Memorial decisions are not emergencies. They don’t expire. Waiting is not avoidance. It is wisdom. Grief has its own timeline, and the brain slowly follows.
In my work, I remind families that readiness is quiet. It arrives gently, often months later, when choices feel less frantic and more true. Until then, your only job is to breathe, to rest your mind, and to trust that clarity will return—when it’s meant to.
Cathy Sanchez Babao
Parting Stone Grief Coach
If you're reading this because grief decision making feels impossible right now, you're not experiencing weakness or failure. You're experiencing exactly what neuroscience tells us happens to every human brain during bereavement. Your difficulty concentrating, remembering details, or feeling confident about choices isn't a personal flaw. It's your brain's protective response to trauma.
The pressure to make important decisions while grieving creates a painful contradiction. Just when life demands crucial choices about finances, living arrangements, or honoring your loved one's memory, your mental capacity for wise decision-making has been temporarily compromised. This isn't your fault, and understanding why this happens can help you navigate this challenging time with greater self-compassion and practical wisdom.
The Hidden Problem: How Grief Hijacks Your Decision-Making Brain
The Neuroscience of Grief Brain
When you lose someone important, your brain doesn't just process emotional pain. Research published in neuroscience journals reveals that grief literally rewires your neural pathways in ways that make clear thinking nearly impossible.
Your prefrontal cortex, the brain region responsible for executive functions like planning, reasoning, and weighing consequences, becomes significantly less active during acute grief. Meanwhile, your limbic system, designed for survival responses, takes control. According to recent neuroimaging studies, this creates what researchers call "competitive neurocognitive processes" where emotional survival mechanisms override logical analysis.
Chris from Illinois 🖤 experienced this firsthand: "While my mother had left instructions to be cremated, she left little else regarding what to do after that. When the Parting Stone idea was presented to us, it was like a weight was lifted off our shoulders."
The result is what grief counselors term "grief brain" or "grief fog" - a state where simple tasks feel overwhelming and complex decisions seem impossible. Clinical research demonstrates that people experiencing intense grief show measurable deficits in attention, processing speed, working memory, and emotional decision-making compared to non-bereaved individuals.
Why Traditional Advice Fails
Well-meaning friends and family often encourage quick decision-making after loss, believing that "staying busy" or "making progress" will help healing. This approach fundamentally misunderstands how grief affects cognitive function. Studies on bereavement and cognitive functioning show that pushing for premature decisions often leads to:
- Choice regret when thinking clarity returns
- Financial losses from decisions made without proper evaluation
- Family conflicts arising from choices that don't reflect actual values
- Memorial decisions that feel hollow or inappropriate later
The pressure intensifies because grief affects time perception. Days blend together, deadlines feel arbitrary, and the future seems impossible to envision. Your brain, focused on processing trauma, simply cannot allocate sufficient resources to complex decision-making processes.
@chloebluffcakes Thank you @partingstone 🤍 youve given me an unimaginable gift. One day I will share these with my little sister and carry her wherever we go in life together. #grief #partingstone #loss
♬ Repeat Until Death - Novo Amor
The Memorial Decision Dilemma
Memorial choices present particularly complex challenges because they feel both urgent and permanent. Funeral directors, family members, and cultural expectations often create pressure to decide quickly about cremated remains, burial plots, or memorial services.
Margaret 🖤 from our customer research struggled with this exact challenge: "I needed time to be ready. I hoped I hadn't waited too long, but I want to honor both my timeline and his memory." She waited two years before making her memorial decision and felt anxious about whether her timing was appropriate.
This pressure creates what researchers call "forced choice stress" - the psychological strain of making important decisions before emotional and cognitive readiness. Unlike medical emergencies requiring immediate action, most memorial decisions can be delayed without negative consequences, allowing your natural decision-making capacity to recover.
Understanding Your Guide: The Timeline of Cognitive Recovery
The Acute Phase (0-6 Months): Survival Mode
During the first six months after loss, your brain operates in protective crisis mode. Psychological research on grief stages shows that this period involves:
- Severe attention deficits making it difficult to focus on complex information
- Memory consolidation problems where new information doesn't stick
- Emotional dysregulation causing decisions to feel overwhelming
- Time distortion where days, weeks, or months seem unreal
Maria from Pennsylvania 🖤 described this experience: "We lost our dad at 96. It's hard to put into words opening the packages that day and holding a piece of him. That meant more than I can even put into words."
During this phase, avoid major financial, legal, or life decisions whenever possible. Your brain is simply not equipped for complex analysis. Focus on basic daily functioning and immediate necessities only.
The Processing Phase (6-18 Months): Gradual Clearing
Between six and eighteen months, most people experience gradual improvement in cognitive function. Research on grief trajectories indicates that this period involves:
- Slowly returning concentration for longer periods
- Improved memory formation and recall capabilities
- Beginning emotional stability with fewer extreme mood swings
- Realistic future thinking starting to emerge
This is when many people begin researching memorial options, considering major life changes, or evaluating financial situations. However, decision-making capacity remains compromised compared to pre-loss levels.
Thomas from Illinois 🖤 reflected on his timeline: "Finding your product was meant to be. I was pleasantly surprised that I received 93 stones. More than enough to share. Great company, great experience."
The Integration Phase (18+ Months): Restored Capacity
Most people see significant improvement in decision-making ability after eighteen months, though individual timelines vary greatly. Longitudinal studies of bereaved individuals show that this phase typically includes:
- Restored executive function for planning and analysis
- Improved emotional regulation during stress
- Realistic risk assessment capabilities return
- Future-oriented thinking becomes possible again
Carole from Tennessee 🖤 experienced this natural timeline: "It has been comforting to have him here. Many times I reach for him for comfort on the sofa, or going somewhere unfamiliar. Also, when I visit family, it's great to take him with me."
Understanding these phases helps normalize your experience and provides realistic expectations for when major decision-making might feel appropriate again.
Your Action Plan: Protecting Yourself During Vulnerable Times
When Decisions Cannot Wait
Some decisions simply cannot be postponed, regardless of your cognitive state. The goal isn't to avoid all choices, but to protect yourself from poor decisions while handling unavoidable ones.
Create a Decision Support System:
- Identify 2-3 trusted advisors who knew you before your loss
- Ask them to help evaluate major choices against your historical values
- Request that they point out if decisions seem unlike your usual pattern
- Establish a "cooling off" period for any choice over $1,000 or with long-term consequences
Use the 24-48-72 Rule:
- Wait 24 hours before any significant decision
- Wait 48 hours for major financial choices
- Wait 72 hours for life-changing decisions
- If pressure mounts, explain that this is medical necessity, not indecision
Phillip from Minnesota 🖤 found support crucial: "A friend of ours had this done. When my wife was diagnosed with stage four cancer, she was the one that decided this is what she wanted. I supported her then and am glad that this is what she wanted."
Memorial Decisions: The Gift of Time
Unlike medical emergencies, memorial decisions rarely require immediate action. Cremated remains can remain safely stored while you develop emotional and cognitive readiness for meaningful choices.
Elizabeth from Connecticut 🖤 discovered this freedom: "Being able to hold my mom close and place her in her favorite spots has been incredibly powerful. Our entire family and close friends have a piece of her and it means the world to us."
Many families find that delaying memorial decisions until genuine readiness leads to more meaningful and satisfying outcomes. There's no medical, legal, or practical requirement to make permanent memorial choices during acute grief.
This is where understanding your options becomes valuable. Solidified remains offer a complete alternative to traditional cremated remains, transforming ashes into smooth, meaningful stones through an 8-10 week scientific process. Unlike urns or keepsakes, this creates a new form of remains that can be held, shared among family members, and incorporated into daily life when you feel ready.
The service, available for $2,495 for human remains, allows families to delay permanent decisions while preserving all remains in a form that eliminates common concerns about ash storage, transport, or division among loved ones.
Financial and Legal Protections
Immediate Actions to Take:
- Notify all financial institutions of your loss and cognitive vulnerability
- Request that major account changes require written confirmation with 7-day delays
- Ask trusted advisors to review any legal documents before signing
- Consider temporary powers of attorney for complex decisions
Red Flags to Recognize:
- Pressure to decide immediately without consultation time
- Decisions that require depleting emergency funds
- Choices that contradict your historical values or preferences
- Anything that feels overwhelming despite being "simple"
Creating Cognitive Breathing Room
Environmental Modifications:
- Reduce daily decision load by simplifying routine choices
- Use timers and written reminders for important tasks
- Ask others to handle non-essential decisions temporarily
- Create quiet spaces for the few decisions you must make
Emotional Supports:
- Join grief support groups to normalize your experience
- Work with counselors familiar with grief's cognitive effects
- Connect with others who've navigated similar decisions successfully
- Practice self-compassion when thinking feels difficult
Karen from Toronto 🖤 emphasized the importance of support: "From beginning to end, the story of my loved one was treated with openness, curiosity, dignity and respect."
How to Tell When You're Ready
Signs of Returning Cognitive Capacity
Concentration Improvements:
- Ability to read for 30+ minutes without losing focus
- Following complex conversations or TV shows completely
- Completing multi-step tasks without written reminders
- Making routine decisions without feeling overwhelmed
Memory Stabilization:
- Remembering new information consistently
- Recalling recent events accurately
- Finding misplaced items more easily
- Following through on commitments without extra reminders
Emotional Regulation:
- Fewer extreme mood swings throughout the day
- Ability to discuss the future without panic
- Managing stress without feeling completely overwhelmed
- Making small decisions without extended anxiety
Future Orientation:
- Considering consequences beyond immediate needs
- Making plans weeks or months in advance
- Evaluating options based on long-term values
- Feeling curious about new possibilities
The Memorial Readiness Test
Before making significant memorial decisions, honestly assess whether you can:
- Explain your choice to someone else clearly and logically
- Imagine how you'll feel about this decision in five years
- Consider alternatives without feeling pressured or rushed
- Connect the decision to your actual values and the relationship you had
- Handle potential regret if circumstances change later
Sheila from Kansas 🖤 recognized her readiness: "Mark and I lived to travel, he made me promise not to stop. The stones are a tangible symbol of our love for a kind, amazing man."
Success: Life After Grief Brain
What Recovery Looks Like
Cognitive restoration after grief doesn't mean returning to exactly who you were before. Most people emerge with:
- Enhanced appreciation for meaningful relationships and experiences
- Improved ability to distinguish between urgent and important decisions
- Greater compassion for others facing difficult choices
- Deeper understanding of what truly matters in life
Becky from Wisconsin 🖤 reflected on her transformation: "The stones bring comfort to us all. It's so much nicer to share the stones with family rather than one urn sitting on a shelf."
Memorial Decisions Made from Strength
When memorial decisions arise from genuine readiness rather than external pressure, families consistently report:
- Greater satisfaction with choices that reflect actual values
- Reduced family conflict around memorial approaches
- More meaningful experiences incorporating the memorial into daily life
- Peace about timing that honors both grief process and memory
James from Arizona 🖤 experienced this journey: "I believe your brochure should explain that it is a minimum 10-week process from when they receive the remains." His feedback shows someone cognitively engaged and thinking practically about future customers.
Building Decision-Making Confidence
As cognitive capacity returns, practice with smaller decisions helps rebuild confidence:
- Start with low-stakes choices and gradually increase complexity
- Notice when decisions feel authentic versus pressured
- Celebrate successful choices made from your restored capacity
- Trust your rebuilt decision-making skills for future challenges
Most importantly, remember that honoring your own timeline is not selfish or weak. It's a crucial part of making decisions that truly serve both your wellbeing and your loved one's memory.
How to Navigate Memorial Decisions When Ready
Understanding Solidified Remains
When you feel genuinely ready for memorial decisions, understanding modern alternatives can provide meaningful options. Solidified remains represent a complete departure from traditional cremation outcomes, transforming cremated remains into a collection of smooth, stone-like forms through a scientific process developed with Los Alamos National Laboratory.
Unlike memorial products or urns, this creates a new form of remains rather than a container or keepsake. The 8-10 week process uses the vast majority of original cremated remains, eliminating common concerns about ash storage, transport anxiety, or division among family members.
Maria from Pennsylvania 🖤 described the emotional impact: "I can't tell you the emotions opening the box that day in our living room. It was a piece of him that we could hold and touch. The sheer emotions of the grown grandkids was just something special."
Practical Benefits for Families
Shareability: Multiple family members can each have meaningful portions without the discomfort of dividing ashes
Portability: Stones travel easily for visits, special occasions, or memorial trips without spill anxiety
Tactile Comfort: Smooth stones can be held, carried, or kept nearby without the concerns many people feel about touching cremated remains
Display Options: Stones integrate naturally into homes, gardens, or memorial spaces without requiring special urns
Making the Decision When Ready
The investment of $2,495 for human remains ($1,195 for pet remains) reflects the scientific precision and individual attention required for the transformation process. Most families find this meaningful when they've reached genuine decision-making readiness rather than feeling pressured during acute grief.
Chris from Illinois 🖤 appreciated having time to understand: "We had never heard of anything like this before. The ability to take our loved one with us to our family's favorite places, and leave a little part behind, is priceless."
Frequently Asked Questions
Should you make major decisions while grieving?
Generally no. Research demonstrates that grief significantly impairs cognitive functions needed for sound decision-making, including attention, memory, and emotional regulation. Most major decisions can wait 6-18 months while your brain's natural healing process restores decision-making capacity.
How long does grief affect decision-making?
Individual timelines vary greatly, but studies show most people see significant improvement in cognitive function between 6-18 months after loss. Acute effects typically last 3-6 months, with gradual improvement continuing for up to two years. If cognitive difficulties persist beyond 12 months or worsen over time, consider professional support.
What decisions absolutely cannot wait during grief?
Essential decisions include: medical care for yourself or dependents, basic financial obligations like mortgage or rent, immediate childcare arrangements, and legally required choices with firm deadlines. However, most memorial, major financial, career, or relationship decisions can be postponed without negative consequences.
How do you know when you're ready to make memorial decisions?
Signs of readiness include: ability to concentrate for extended periods, stable mood and sleep patterns, capacity to imagine the future realistically, and feeling genuinely curious about options rather than pressured. You should be able to clearly explain your choice to others and feel confident about living with the decision long-term.
Can family pressure you into grief decisions?
Yes, and this is unfortunately common. Well-meaning relatives often push for quick memorial decisions, believing activity helps healing. Grief counseling research shows that premature decisions frequently lead to regret when cognitive clarity returns. It's medically appropriate to request time for your decision-making capacity to recover.
What if you've already made decisions you regret?
Many grief decisions can be modified or reversed when you're thinking more clearly. Memorial choices often have flexible elements, financial decisions can sometimes be adjusted, and relationship changes can be reconsidered. Focus on learning from the experience rather than self-blame, and consider professional guidance for significant corrections.
About the Editor
Cathy Sanchez Babao is a Grief Coach at Parting Stone, a grief educator, counselor, author, and columnist who has dedicated her career to helping individuals and families navigate loss. She writes the “Roots and Wings” column for the Philippine Daily Inquirer and is the author of Heaven’s Butterfly and Between Loss and Forever: Filipina Mothers on the Grief Journey. Cathy holds a B.S. in Business Administration and Management from Ateneo de Manila University and an M.A. in Family Psychology and Education from Miriam College, with advanced grief training at the Center for Loss & Life Transition and the Center for Prolonged Grief at Columbia University.
References
Boelen, P. A., van den Bout, J., & van den Hout, M. A. (2006). Negative cognitions and avoidance in emotional problems after bereavement: A prospective study. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 44(11), 1657-1672. https://psycnet.apa.org/doi/10.1016/j.brat.2005.12.006
Fernández-Alcántara, M., Zech, E., Wainrib, B. R., Carrera-González, M. P., Dickinson, P., Bacqué, M. F., & Quintana-Orts, C. (2016). Grief experiences and emotional processing in adults: A comparison between men and women. Death Studies, 40(10), 658-665. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07481187.2016.1198870
Maccallum, F., & Bryant, R. A. (2019). A cognitive attachment model of prolonged grief: Integrating attachment, memory, and identity. Clinical Psychology Review, 65, 26-38. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272735818301903
O'Connor, M. F., Arizmendi, B. J., & Kaszniak, A. W. (2014). Virtually compassionate: A review of virtual reality in grief counseling. Behavior Research and Therapy, 61, 18-28. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0005796714001478
O'Connor, M. F., Wellisch, D. K., Stanton, A. L., Eisenberger, N. I., Irwin, M. R., & Lieberman, M. D. (2008). Craving love? Enduring grief activates brain's reward center. NeuroImage, 42(2), 969-972. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1053811908005739
Saavedra Pérez, H. C., Ikram, M. A., Direk, N., Prigerson, H. G., Freak-Poli, R., Verhaaren, B. F., ... & Tiemeier, H. (2015). Cognition, structural brain changes and complicated grief: A population-based study. Psychological Medicine, 45(7), 1389-1399. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/psychological-medicine/article/abs/cognition-structural-brain-changes-and-complicated-grief-a-populationbased-study/F3C176989354AE790A72EA0EE905D964
Shulman, I. (2018). A Beginner's Guide to the End: Practical Advice for Living Life and Facing Death. Simon & Schuster. https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/A-Beginners-Guide-to-the-End/BJ-Miller/9781501157264
Skritskaya, N. A., Mauro, C., Olonoff, M., Fernandez, T., Margolies, M., Reynolds, C. F., ... & Shear, M. K. (2017). Measuring maladaptive cognitions in complicated grief: Introducing the Typical Beliefs Questionnaire. American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 25(5), 541-550. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1064748117300964
You're Not Alone in Wanting Something Better
If you're here, you likely understand something that 75 million Americans are still discovering: traditional cremated remains often create more anxiety than comfort.
Families who choose solidified remains share a common understanding: your loved one deserves better than to be hidden away in a closet, garage, or basement. They deserve a memorial that you can interact with, share with family members, and incorporate into the meaningful moments of your life.
These families understand that premium memorial solutions aren't about spending more—they're about choosing something that actually serves the emotional needs of grief and healing.
