When Grief Won't Let You Cry (Or Won't Let You Stop)

Reviewed By:

Cathy Sanchez Babao

Mental Health Advocate • Grief Coach • Certified Grief Recovery Method Specialist • Award-Winning Author • M.A. Family Psychology & Education (Miriam College) • Advanced Grief Training (Center for Loss & Life Transition & Columbia University)

Key Takeaways

• It's completely normal to not cry during grief - tears are just one way your body processes loss, and absence of crying doesn't mean you love them any less or that your grief isn't real
• Crying patterns vary dramatically between individuals and can change throughout your grief journey, influenced by personality, culture, past experiences, and neurological factors
• Both excessive crying and inability to cry can signal your nervous system's response to trauma - neither pattern indicates you're grieving "wrong"
• Your emotional expression affects your readiness to make memorial decisions - honoring where you are emotionally can guide timing for meaningful choices
• Professional support is available when crying patterns cause distress or interfere with daily functioning, and seeking help is a sign of strength, not weakness

The question haunts you in quiet moments: Why can't I cry? Or perhaps the opposite torments you: Why can't I stop crying? In a world that expects grief to look a certain way, you might feel broken when your tears don't match what others seem to expect.

Whether you're three months into grief with dry eyes that won't release, or six months in and still crying every day, you're not alone in wondering if your emotional response is normal. The truth is both more complex and more comforting than you might expect.

The Hidden Crisis: When Grief Doesn't Look Like the Movies

Grief rarely follows the neat patterns we see in films or read about in books. Your emotional expression during loss is as unique as your fingerprint, shaped by everything from your neurology to your childhood experiences to the specific relationship you had with the person who died.

Yet society often expects grief to follow a predictable pattern: initial shock, appropriate tears, gradual healing, and eventual acceptance. When your grief doesn't conform to these expectations, you might feel like you're failing at something that should come naturally.

Natalie from California 🖤 describes her experience: "When I first got them, I felt a rush of emotion and found myself hugging the box and crying (happy/sad tears). It provided another way to work through some of my grief surrounding my mom's passing." Her tears came not immediately after loss, but months later when she found a meaningful way to connect with her mother's memory.

The reality is that grief affects our nervous systems in ways that can temporarily or permanently alter how we express emotions. Some people become hypervigilant and unable to access tears, while others find their emotional regulation completely overwhelmed. Both responses are protective mechanisms your body has developed to help you survive an unbearable experience.

The Science Behind Tears and Grief

Understanding Your Body's Grief Response

When someone significant dies, your nervous system experiences what researchers call "biological grief" - a measurable change in stress hormones, neurotransmitters, and even immune function (Shear, 2015). This biological upheaval affects everything from sleep patterns to digestion, and yes, your ability to cry.

Tears themselves serve multiple functions beyond emotional expression. Emotional tears contain higher levels of stress hormones than other types of tears, literally helping your body release tension and toxins (Bylsma et al., 2008). But grief can disrupt this natural release mechanism in several ways:

Trauma Response Patterns:

• Hyperarousal can keep you in a state where tears feel impossible, as if your emotional system is frozen
• Hypoarousal might leave you feeling emotionally numb, disconnected from the feelings that would normally trigger tears
• Dissociation can create a sense that the loss isn't real, blocking the emotional connection needed for crying

Neurological Factors:

• Antidepressants and anxiety medications can reduce tear production as a side effect
• Sleep deprivation from grief-related insomnia affects emotional regulation
• Hormonal changes, especially in women, can influence crying patterns significantly

Cultural and Personal Influences on Emotional Expression

Your family of origin taught you rules about crying that you might not even consciously remember. Some families encourage emotional expression, while others prioritize strength and stoicism. Neither approach is wrong, but both shape how comfortable you feel with tears during grief.

Cultural background also plays a significant role. Mediterranean and Latin cultures often encourage emotional expression during loss, while many Northern European and East Asian cultures emphasize emotional control. Your genetic heritage might influence both your emotional temperament and your cultural conditioning around tears.

AmberElizabeth from New Mexico 🖤, who works as a trauma and grief therapist, explains: "The most challenging thing people express when they lose a loved one is the loss of physical presence. Parting stones are brilliant because they are tangible in ways that are comforting when held, assuring when viewed, and spark creative expression of grief." Her professional understanding helps her see that healing often comes through tangible connection rather than just emotional expression.

Individual Differences: Why Your Grief Looks Different

Personality and Temperament Factors

Introverts often process grief internally before external expression, which might mean weeks or months before tears come, if they come at all. Extroverts might cry immediately but then feel guilty about "putting their emotions on others." Neither pattern indicates the depth of your loss.

Research shows that people with higher emotional intelligence don't necessarily cry more - they're often better at recognizing and managing their emotions through multiple channels (Salovey & Mayer, 1990). You might be processing grief through physical activities, creative expression, or deep thinking rather than tears.

The Gender Factor in Grief Expression

While generalizations can be harmful, research does show some patterns in how different genders typically express grief:

Common patterns often seen in women:

• More likely to cry openly and seek emotional support
• May feel pressure to be emotional caretakers while grieving
• Hormonal cycles can intensify or suppress emotional expression

Common patterns often seen in men:

• May express grief through anger, action, or withdrawal rather than tears
• Often face social pressure to "be strong" for others
• May have fewer models for emotional expression during loss

Important note: These are tendencies, not rules. Your grief expression is valid regardless of your gender identity or how it compares to statistical norms.

When Medical Factors Affect Crying

Several medical conditions can impact your ability to cry during grief:

• Sjögren's syndrome and other autoimmune conditions affect tear production
• Depression can either increase crying or create emotional numbness
• Anxiety disorders might keep you in a hypervigilant state where tears feel impossible
• Hormonal changes from menopause, thyroid issues, or medications can affect emotional expression

If you're concerned about your inability to cry, discussing this with a healthcare provider can help rule out medical factors while validating that your grief expression is still completely valid.

Understanding Excessive Crying in Grief

When Tears Won't Stop

For some grieving people, the challenge isn't accessing tears but managing overwhelming emotional expression. You might find yourself crying multiple times daily, weeks or months after the loss, feeling like you're drowning in emotions.

Sophie from Texas 🖤 shares her experience: "The ability to hold such a soft stone in my hand is so soothing. Every stone is so beautiful and so comforting. Having the option of choosing something special for those that wanted to keep a special memory was so important." She found comfort in tangible connection when her emotions felt overwhelming.

Excessive crying during grief might indicate:

• Complicated grief, where the intensity of emotions doesn't naturally decrease over time
• Underlying depression that was triggered or worsened by the loss
• Trauma responses if the death was sudden, violent, or particularly shocking
• Hormonal fluctuations that amplify emotional responses

The Physical Toll of Constant Tears

Crying frequently over extended periods can physically exhaust you. The stress hormones released during intense emotional episodes can disrupt sleep, appetite, and immune function. You might experience:

• Severe headaches from dehydration and tension
• Swollen eyes and facial puffiness
• Fatigue that doesn't improve with rest
• Difficulty concentrating or making decisions

This doesn't mean you should suppress your emotions, but it does mean you need extra self-care during periods of intense grieving.

Supporting Yourself Through Different Crying Patterns

If You Can't Cry When You Want To

The inability to cry can feel like being emotionally constipated - you sense the feelings inside but can't release them. This is incredibly common and doesn't reflect your love for the person who died.

Gentle approaches that might help:

• Physical movement like walking, swimming, or yoga can sometimes unlock emotional release
• Journaling your thoughts and memories, even if tears don't come
• Looking at photos or videos of your loved one in a safe, private space
• Listening to music that held special meaning in your relationship
• Talking with trusted friends about your loved one's life and your relationship

Important reminder: You don't need to force tears. Grief healing happens through many pathways, and crying is just one of them.

If You Can't Stop Crying

Frequent crying during grief is also completely normal, especially in the first year after loss. However, if crying interferes with your ability to work, care for yourself, or maintain relationships, you deserve additional support.

Strategies for managing overwhelming emotions:

• Create designated crying times - allow yourself 15-20 minutes of intentional emotional release daily
• Practice grounding techniques like the 5-4-3-2-1 method when crying feels out of control
• Stay hydrated and nourish yourself, as frequent crying depletes your body's resources
• Reach out for professional support if crying episodes increase rather than naturally decrease over time

Alessandra from Florida 🖤 describes how physical comfort helped: "Having the ability to carry pieces of her has helped it hurt less because I can hold her and kiss her when the grief is especially overwhelming." Sometimes tangible comfort can provide stability when emotions feel chaotic.

How Emotional Expression Connects to Memorial Decisions

Understanding Your Readiness Timeline

Your crying patterns often reflect your emotional readiness to make significant decisions about honoring your loved one's memory. This isn't about rushing or forcing decisions, but understanding how your emotional state affects your capacity for meaningful choices.

If you're in a period where tears won't come:

• You might be in a protective state where major decisions feel overwhelming
• Your logical mind might be more accessible, but emotional connection to choices might feel difficult
• Taking time for emotional readiness is not only okay, it's wise

If you're in a period of frequent crying:

• You might feel emotionally raw and vulnerable to making decisions you'll later question
• Gentle exploration of options might feel supportive, but commitment might feel premature
• Your emotional sensitivity might make you more aware of what truly matters

Kerry from Oregon 🖤 found that memorial decisions became clearer over time: "This was a great opportunity to have our loved one's remains close by, but not just 'in a box.' They get to be displayed, touched, and carried with us whenever we need to feel close." Her words reflect someone who had processed enough to know what kind of connection she needed.

When Families Are Ready for Solidified Remains

Many families discover that solidified remains offer a unique form of comfort that works regardless of their crying patterns. Unlike traditional ashes that can feel overwhelming or disconnected, the smooth, touchable stones provide gentle comfort without emotional overwhelm.

The transformation process takes approximately 8-10 weeks, during which families often find their emotional readiness naturally develops. At $2,495 for human remains and $1,195 for pet remains, the service represents a complete alternative to traditional ashes rather than an additional purchase.

MaryJayne from New Mexico 🖤 reflects on her experience: "I think having the stones rather than just ashes is that the stones are beautiful, they can be shared with loved ones and can be placed in sites that were meaningful. My stones are beautiful and hold deep meaning for me. When I place a stone at a special site, I feel like it is a blessing to my loved one."

The decision to transform cremated remains into solidified remains often feels right when:

• You're seeking tangible comfort that doesn't trigger overwhelming emotions
• You want to share your loved one's memory with family members in a meaningful way
• Traditional urns feel too formal or disconnected from your relationship
• You desire the flexibility to keep some remains close while placing others in special locations

How To Support Your Unique Grief Expression

Creating Safe Spaces for Whatever Comes

Honoring your grief means accepting whatever emotional expression feels authentic in each moment. This might change from day to day, hour to hour, and that's completely normal.

Steps for emotional self-care:

1. Establish daily check-ins with yourself - Notice what you're feeling without judgment
2. Create private spaces where you can express emotions freely without others' expectations
3. Develop comfort rituals that soothe you regardless of whether tears come
4. Connect with understanding people who don't pressure you to grieve in a particular way
5. Practice radical self-acceptance about your unique grief journey

Building Your Support Network

Different people might support different aspects of your grief. Some friends might be wonderful listeners, while others might be better at distracting you when you need a break. Some family members might understand your tears, while others might better support you when emotions feel frozen.

Rebecca from Connecticut 🖤 shares: "Amazing. I feel like Justin is with me wherever I go. This is a tangible way to hold him and bring him with me." Her words reflect someone who found support through meaningful connection rather than just emotional expression.

Consider reaching out to:

• Grief support groups where crying patterns vary widely
• Spiritual or religious communities that honor different expressions of loss
• Mental health professionals who specialize in grief and trauma
• Online communities where you can connect anonymously with others experiencing similar patterns

When to Seek Professional Support

Recognizing When You Need Additional Help

Seeking professional support isn't a sign of failure - it's recognition that grief can overwhelm even our best coping mechanisms. Consider reaching out to a grief counselor or therapist if:

For those who can't cry:

• You feel completely disconnected from your emotions for weeks at a time
• You're using substances, workaholism, or other behaviors to avoid feelings
• Friends and family express concern about your emotional withdrawal
• You feel like you're "going through the motions" of life without really living

For those crying frequently:

• Crying episodes increase rather than gradually decrease over several months
• You can't function at work, school, or home due to overwhelming emotions
• You're having thoughts of joining your loved one or that life isn't worth living
• Physical symptoms from frequent crying are affecting your health

Types of Professional Support Available

Grief counselors specialize in understanding the wide range of normal grief responses and can help you navigate your unique pattern without pathologizing it.

Trauma therapists are particularly helpful if the death was sudden, violent, or if you're experiencing symptoms like nightmares, flashbacks, or severe anxiety.

Support groups connect you with others who understand that grief doesn't follow rules about crying or emotional expression.

Medical providers can help rule out physical factors affecting your ability to cry and discuss medication options if depression or anxiety are complicating your grief.

Finding Peace in Your Unique Journey

Releasing Expectations About How Grief Should Look

The most healing thing you can do is release the idea that there's a "right" way to grieve. Your tears or lack of tears don't measure your love. Your timeline doesn't need to match anyone else's. Your emotional expression is valid exactly as it is.

Carolyn from Nebraska 🖤 found meaning in sharing her experience: "Due to health concerns and financial difficulties, his siblings were unable to see him before he passed. They cherished this tangible gift of their brother." Her story shows how healing can come through connection and meaning-making rather than specific emotional expressions.

Moving Forward in Your Own Time

Grief is not a problem to be solved but an experience to be lived. Some days you might cry, some days you might feel numb, and some days you might feel surprisingly peaceful. All of these experiences are part of your unique grief journey.

When you're ready - and only when you're ready - you might find yourself naturally drawn to decisions about how to honor your loved one's memory. This readiness isn't tied to crying patterns or specific timelines. It emerges from your own inner wisdom about what feels right for your relationship with the person who died.

Whether that means keeping cremated remains as they are, choosing burial, or transforming them into solidified remains, the right choice is the one that brings you comfort and connection to your loved one's memory.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal to not cry when someone close to me dies?

Absolutely. Not crying doesn't mean you don't care or that you're not grieving properly. Many people process grief through other emotional and physical responses. Factors like personality, past experiences, cultural background, medications, and individual neurology all influence crying patterns. Your grief is valid regardless of tears.

Why do I cry at unexpected times but not during the funeral or memorial?

Delayed emotional responses are incredibly common in grief. During formal ceremonies, you might be in "survival mode," focused on getting through the day. Tears often come later when your nervous system feels safe enough to release emotions, sometimes triggered by seemingly unrelated moments that remind you of your loss.

Could medication be affecting my ability to cry during grief?

Yes, certain medications can reduce tear production or emotional expression. Antidepressants, particularly SSRIs, anxiety medications, blood pressure medications, and antihistamines can all affect crying. If you're concerned, discuss this with your healthcare provider, but remember that medication effects don't invalidate your grief.

When does frequent crying become concerning during grief?

Frequent crying is normal, especially in the first year after loss. However, seek professional support if crying episodes are increasing rather than naturally fluctuating, if you can't function in daily life, if you're having thoughts of suicide, or if physical effects from crying are impacting your health significantly.

How do I explain my crying pattern to family members who don't understand?

Help them understand that grief affects everyone differently. You might say: "I know my grief doesn't look like yours, but this is how my body and mind are processing this loss right now. I need you to support me where I am rather than where you think I should be." Consider sharing educational resources about different grief expressions.

Can changing how I'm honoring my loved one's memory affect my emotional expression?

Many families find that memorial decisions do impact their grief experience. Some people feel more emotionally settled after making meaningful choices about their loved one's remains, whether that's traditional burial, keeping ashes, or choosing solidified remains. The key is making decisions that feel right for your unique relationship and emotional needs.

About the Editor

Cathy Sanchez Babao

Cathy Sanchez Babao is a Grief Coach at Parting Stone, a grief educator, counselor, author, and columnist who has dedicated her career to helping individuals and families navigate loss. She writes the “Roots and Wings” column for the Philippine Daily Inquirer and is the author of Heaven’s Butterfly and Between Loss and Forever: Filipina Mothers on the Grief Journey. Cathy holds a B.S. in Business Administration and Management from Ateneo de Manila University and an M.A. in Family Psychology and Education from Miriam College, with advanced grief training at the Center for Loss & Life Transition and the Center for Prolonged Grief at Columbia University.

References

Bonanno, G. A. (2004). Loss, trauma, and human resilience: Have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events? American Psychologist, 59(1), 20-28. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.59.1.20

Bylsma, L. M., Vingerhoets, A. J., & Rottenberg, J. (2008). When is crying cathartic? An international study. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 27(10), 1165-1187. https://doi.org/10.1521/jscp.2008.27.10.1165

Worden, J. W. (2018). Grief counseling and grief therapy: A handbook for the mental health practitioner (5th ed.). Springer Publishing Company.

Shear, M. K. (2015). Complicated grief. New England Journal of Medicine, 372(2), 153-160. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMcp1315618

Stroebe, M., Schut, H., & Stroebe, W. (2007). Health outcomes of bereavement. The Lancet, 370(9603), 1960-1973. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(07)61816-9

Salovey, P., & Mayer, J. D. (1990). Emotional intelligence. Imagination, Cognition and Personality, 9(3), 185-211. https://doi.org/10.2190/DUGG-P24E-52WK-6CDG

National Alliance on Mental Illness. (2022). Grief and loss. NAMI Resource Guide. https://www.nami.org/About-Mental-Illness/Related-Conditions/Grief-and-Loss

Klass, D., Silverman, P. R., & Nickman, S. L. (Eds.). (1996). Continuing bonds: New understandings of grief. Taylor & Francis.

Wolfelt, A. D. (2016). The wilderness of grief: Finding your way. Companion Press.

Rando, T. A. (1986). Parental loss of a child. Research Press.