Memorial Questions to Ask Yourself Before Deciding

Reviewed By:

Cathy Sanchez Babao

Mental Health Advocate • Grief Coach • Certified Grief Recovery Method Specialist • Award-Winning Author • M.A. Family Psychology & Education (Miriam College) • Advanced Grief Training (Center for Loss & Life Transition & Columbia University)

Key Takeaways

• Memorial decisions benefit from values-based self-reflection rather than rushed choices during intense grief periods
• Essential questions focus on honoring your loved one authentically while considering your family's unique needs and circumstances
• Taking time for thoughtful consideration leads to more meaningful outcomes that provide lasting comfort and connection
• Professional guidance and trusted support systems can help navigate complex emotions during the decision-making process
• Memorial choices should reflect both your loved one's wishes and your family's healing journey moving forward

When someone you love dies, the weight of memorial decisions can feel overwhelming. You want to honor them perfectly, yet you're navigating this choice during one of life's most emotionally challenging times. Many families find themselves asking, "How do I choose something meaningful when I can barely think clearly?"

You're not alone in feeling uncertain about memorial decisions. The desire to make the "right" choice is natural and shows your deep love for the person who died. However, rushing into decisions during intense grief can sometimes lead to choices that don't truly reflect what matters most to you and your family.

This comprehensive guide provides essential memorial questions before deciding on any memorial option. These self-reflection prompts will help you move through the decision-making process thoughtfully, ensuring your choice aligns with your values, honors your loved one authentically, and supports your family's healing journey.

The Hidden Challenge of Memorial Decision-Making

Why Memorial Choices Feel So Difficult

Memorial decisions carry enormous emotional weight because they represent how we'll remember and honor someone forever. Unlike other purchases, there's no opportunity to return or exchange something that doesn't feel right. This permanence, combined with grief's natural impact on decision-making, creates a perfect storm of pressure and uncertainty.

Research from grief counseling professionals indicates that major decisions made during the first six months after loss often need to be revisited later as families gain clarity about their true needs and values. As grief counselor Jill Cohen explains, "The death of a loved one is one of the most stressful events a person can endure in a lifetime... Grief clouds your reactions and responses."

Sarah from New York 🖤 experienced this firsthand: "I was having difficulty deciding on an urn. Parting stones also made it easier to share my husband's remains with our large, close-knit family. He was an avid rock collector as well, so everything about this made sense and has given me peace."

The Cultural Gap in Memorial Guidance

Our culture provides extensive guidance for life's major decisions like choosing a career, buying a home, or planning a wedding. Yet when it comes to memorial choices, families are often left to navigate complex emotional terrain with minimal support or frameworks for decision-making.

This gap becomes more pronounced when we consider that 75 million Americans currently store cremated remains at home without clear next steps. Many families postpone memorial decisions indefinitely, not because they don't care, but because they lack structured approaches to working through their feelings and priorities.

Tracy from Virginia 🖤 shared: "When my Mom passed suddenly, I don't know what I wanted but it was NOT an urn full of ashes to sit neglected for years like my step dad's had been doing. When I found Parting Stone, I was able to have both my parent's remains solidified to something so flexible and so much more meaningful to our family."

Essential Memorial Questions for Self-Reflection

Questions About Your Loved One's Values and Wishes

What did your loved one value most in life? Consider their core principles, spiritual beliefs, and what brought them joy. Did they value simplicity or elegance? Were they environmentally conscious? Did they prefer traditional approaches or innovative solutions?

What did they explicitly express about their memorial preferences? Some people share clear wishes about how they'd like to be remembered or what should happen with their remains. Others never discussed these topics directly but gave hints through their values and life choices.

How did they approach other major life decisions? Understanding their decision-making style can provide insight into what they might have chosen. Were they practical and straightforward? Did they research extensively? Were aesthetics important to them?

Questions About Your Family's Needs

Who needs to be involved in this decision? Memorial choices often affect multiple family members and close friends. Consider who should have input and how to honor different perspectives while maintaining family unity.

What are your family's financial realities? Memorial decisions should align with your financial situation without creating additional stress during grief. Consider both immediate costs and any ongoing expenses.

How do different family members grieve and connect with memories? Some people find comfort in visual reminders, others prefer experiences, and some need tangible connections they can touch and hold.

Nancy from New Mexico 🖤 found meaning in a memorial that matched her family's way of remembering: "I placed the stones around his last project on our property, where we had lived 16 years, and it is a constant reminder of him, but in a great way!"

Questions About Long-term Considerations

How do you envision interacting with this memorial over time? Consider whether you want something you'll visit occasionally, display daily, or carry with you. Think about how your relationship with the memorial might evolve as your grief journey progresses.

What feels sustainable for your family's lifestyle? Some memorial options require ongoing maintenance or care. Consider what feels manageable given your family's circumstances and preferences.

How might your needs change as you heal? Early grief often involves intense closeness to anything connected to the deceased. As healing progresses, families sometimes want different levels of memorial presence in their daily lives.

Questions About Meaning and Connection

What kinds of activities or places felt most special to your loved one? Memorial options that connect to meaningful locations or activities can provide deeper emotional resonance than generic solutions.

How do you want to share your loved one's memory with others? Consider whether you want memorial options that can be shared with family and friends, passed down to future generations, or kept private.

What would feel most honoring to their unique personality and spirit? Move beyond conventional expectations to consider what would truly capture their essence and bring you comfort.

Cindy from Illinois 🖤 found this connection powerful: "I carry a small stone with me everywhere. I love having a little part of my son with me always... Now, wherever we go, we carry a little piece of him with us."

Working Through Conflicting Emotions and Practical Concerns

Navigating "Should" vs "Want"

Many families struggle with tension between what they feel they should do and what they actually want to do. Cultural expectations, family traditions, and perceived social norms can create pressure to choose memorial options that don't align with personal values.

Questions to explore:

• What memorial approach feels right to me, separate from others' expectations?
• Am I choosing based on what others will think or what will truly honor my loved one?
• What would I choose if I knew no one else would judge my decision?

Addressing Financial Concerns Without Guilt

Memorial decisions involve both emotional and financial considerations. It's normal to want meaningful options while being mindful of costs, especially during a time when funeral expenses may have already stretched family budgets.

Healthy approaches to financial considerations:

• Acknowledge that loving someone deeply doesn't require spending beyond your means
• Consider that meaningful memorial experiences often matter more than expensive options
• Remember that your loved one would likely want you to make financially responsible choices

Managing Family Disagreements

When multiple family members are involved in memorial decisions, disagreements can arise about the best approach. These conflicts often reflect different grieving styles rather than fundamental disagreements about honoring the deceased.

Strategies for working through differences:

• Focus on shared values and goals for honoring your loved one
• Allow space for different family members to create their own meaningful connections
• Consider memorial options that can accommodate multiple approaches simultaneously

Memorial Options That Align with Different Values

For Families Prioritizing Environmental Responsibility

Environmental consciousness influences many families' memorial decisions. Traditional burial and cremation both have environmental impacts that concern eco-minded families.

Questions to consider:

• What environmental values did your loved one hold?
• How important is minimizing environmental impact to your family?
• What memorial options align with your sustainability values?

For Families Wanting Flexible, Shareable Options

Some families want memorial approaches that can be divided among multiple family members or used in various meaningful locations over time.

Ginger from Illinois 🖤 appreciated this flexibility: "We loved the idea of leaving stones in the sea instead of just scattering ashes. It also allowed us to hold a tangible piece of our mom's remains and to have a visual reminder of her."

For Families Seeking Innovation and Quality

Families who value technological advancement and superior quality often seek memorial options that reflect these priorities.

Questions for quality-focused families:

• What level of craftsmanship and innovation feels appropriate for honoring your loved one?
• How important is working with providers who use cutting-edge technology and processes?
• What quality standards would your loved one have expected?

Understanding Solidified Remains as a Memorial Option

What Are Solidified Remains?

Solidified remains represent a complete alternative to traditional ash storage, transforming cremated remains into 40-80+ smooth, touchable memorial stones through an innovative process validated by Los Alamos National Laboratory. This option addresses many families' concerns about traditional cremation outcomes while providing meaningful connection and flexibility.

The 8-10 week solidification process creates beautiful stones that can be held, shared among family members, displayed in homes, or placed in meaningful locations. Unlike traditional urns, solidified remains offer families multiple ways to maintain connection with their loved one.

How Solidified Remains Address Common Memorial Concerns

For families struggling with "ash anxiety": Many people feel uncomfortable with the texture, appearance, or unpredictability of cremated remains. Solidified remains eliminate concerns about spillage, exposure to elements, or awkward handling situations.

For families wanting to share remains: Traditional ash division can feel clinical and unsatisfying. Solidified remains create natural portions that feel complete and meaningful for each family member.

For families seeking lasting beauty: The smooth, touchable nature of solidified remains provides aesthetic appeal that feels honoring rather than simply functional.

Lesley from Louisiana 🖤 was surprised by this beauty: "His stones are blue. He had the most beautiful blue eyes. I fully expected gray/beige but his stones are blue... It is a very unique memorial and I love being able to unobtrusively keep him with me wherever I go."

Pricing and Investment Considerations

Solidified remains services are priced at $2,495 for human remains and $1,195 for pet remains, positioning this option as a mid-to-premium memorial choice that offers unique benefits unavailable through other approaches.

When evaluating this investment, families often consider:

• The permanent nature of the memorial solution
• The flexibility to create multiple meaningful experiences over time
• The quality and innovation of the process
• The ability to share meaningfully with multiple family members

How to Work Through Memorial Questions Systematically

Creating Your Decision-Making Framework

Step 1: Gather your thoughts privately first Before discussing options with family members, spend quiet time reflecting on your own feelings and priorities. Grief counselors emphasize the importance of understanding your individual needs before navigating group dynamics.

Step 2: Include trusted advisors gradually Share your reflections with one or two close friends or family members who can provide objective support. Sometimes an outside perspective helps clarify feelings that seem overwhelming when handled alone.

Step 3: Research options thoroughly but without pressure Learn about different memorial approaches during times when you feel emotionally stable, rather than forcing research when grief feels particularly intense.

Step 4: Make decisions when ready, not rushed Memorial choices don't have an arbitrary deadline. Take whatever time feels necessary to reach clarity about the right approach for your family.

Questions for Evaluating Specific Memorial Providers

What is their experience and expertise? Look for providers with established track records, professional credentials, and specialized knowledge in their field.

How do they communicate throughout the process? Quality providers maintain clear, respectful communication and provide realistic timelines for their services.

What guarantees and quality assurances do they offer? Memorial decisions involve significant trust. Reputable providers stand behind their work with clear guarantees and quality commitments.

How do they honor the dignity of your loved one? Every interaction should reflect respect for both your loved one's memory and your family's emotional state.

Melanie from Washington 🖤 appreciated this dignity: "I have 4 siblings and it was a way for each of us to honor our mother in our own unique way. My brother made a border around a lilac bush. Her favorite flower. My artist sister painted some of them."

Creating Space for Emotional Processing

Memorial decisions shouldn't be purely intellectual exercises. Creating space for emotional processing helps ensure your choice aligns with both practical needs and deeper feelings.

Helpful emotional processing approaches:

• Journaling about your loved one's values and your family's needs
• Talking with grief counselors or spiritual advisors
• Visiting meaningful locations where your loved one felt happy
• Looking through photos and remembering what brought them joy

When to Seek Professional Guidance

Signs That Professional Support Would Be Helpful

Persistent decision paralysis: If you've been considering memorial options for several months without making progress, professional guidance can help identify what's blocking forward movement.

Family conflicts about memorial approaches: When family members have strong disagreements about memorial decisions, neutral professional facilitation can help everyone feel heard while working toward solutions.

Overwhelming emotional responses to memorial research: If looking into memorial options consistently triggers intense emotional responses that feel unmanageable, grief counselors can provide support for processing these feelings.

Types of Professional Support Available

Grief counselors specialize in helping people navigate loss and can provide frameworks for memorial decision-making that honor both emotional and practical needs.

Family therapists can facilitate difficult conversations when multiple family members need to reach consensus about memorial approaches.

Spiritual advisors offer perspective on memorial decisions that align with religious or spiritual values and practices.

Moving Forward with Confidence and Peace

Trusting Your Family's Unique Journey

Every family's grief journey is unique, and memorial decisions should reflect your particular circumstances, values, and needs rather than trying to match what others have chosen.

Remember that meaningful memorial decisions:

• Honor your loved one's authentic personality and values
• Provide comfort and connection for your family's healing
• Align with your practical circumstances and capabilities
• Support rather than complicate your grief journey

Creating Ongoing Memorial Meaning

The most powerful memorial decisions often extend beyond the initial choice to create ongoing opportunities for connection and meaning.

James from Georgia 🖤 found this ongoing connection: "She was never one to be tied down, so having her remains sitting in an urn somewhere seemed counter to her. She fought cancer to the end and we continued to adventure while she did that. Helping to leave a piece of her on those adventures has helped keep her alive and honor her."

Whether through special occasions, annual remembrances, or spontaneous moments of connection, memorial choices work best when they support rather than burden your family's natural ways of remembering and honoring your loved one.

Permission to Choose What Feels Right

In a culture that provides limited guidance for memorial decisions, families sometimes worry about making "wrong" choices. You have permission to choose what feels genuinely right for your family, even if it differs from conventional approaches or others' expectations.

Your love for your departed family member shows most clearly through thoughtful consideration of their values and your family's needs, not through conforming to external expectations about memorial "shoulds."

How to Use These Memorial Questions in Practice

1. Creating Your Personal Reflection Process

• Set aside dedicated time for reflection. Memorial decision-making benefits from focused attention rather than rushed consideration between other grief-related tasks.
• Start with the questions that feel most relevant to your situation. You don't need to work through every question if some don't apply to your family's circumstances.
• Write down your initial responses. Grief can impact memory and concentration, so capturing your thoughts in writing helps preserve insights for later consideration.
• Return to your responses after a few days. Initial reactions sometimes change as you process emotions and gain perspective.

2. Involving Family Members Constructively

1. Share your reflection process with family members who will be affected by memorial decisions. Transparency about your thinking helps others understand your perspective and contributes to more productive conversations.
2. Ask family members to work through relevant questions independently first. This prevents group dynamics from overwhelming individual perspectives and ensures everyone's voice is heard.
3. Focus on shared values and goals. When family members have different preferences, identify the underlying values everyone shares about honoring your loved one.

3. Making Your Final Decision

1. Choose when you feel genuinely ready rather than pressured by external timelines. Quality memorial decisions often take longer than family and friends expect, and that's perfectly appropriate.
2. Trust your instincts about what feels right for your family. You know your loved one and your family's needs better than anyone else.
3. Remember that meaningful memorial experiences often matter more than perfect memorial products. The love and intention behind your choice creates meaning, not the specific option you select.

Frequently Asked Questions

What questions should you ask before making memorial decisions?

The most important memorial questions focus on your loved one's values, your family's needs, and long-term considerations for meaning and connection. Essential questions include: What did your loved one value most in life? How do different family members connect with memories? What feels sustainable for your family's lifestyle? How do you want to share their memory with others? These questions help ensure memorial choices align with authentic values rather than external pressures.

How long should I wait before making memorial decisions?

Grief counselors typically recommend waiting at least 6 months before making major life decisions, including permanent memorial choices. However, every family's timeline is different. The key is making decisions when you feel emotionally ready rather than rushed by external pressure. Some families benefit from making temporary arrangements initially, then revisiting memorial decisions when their grief has stabilized and they have greater clarity about their long-term needs.

How do I handle disagreements among family members about memorial choices?

Family disagreements about memorial decisions often reflect different grieving styles rather than fundamental conflicts about honoring the deceased. Focus on identifying shared values about your loved one's memory. Consider memorial options that can accommodate multiple approaches simultaneously, such as solutions that can be divided among family members or used in various meaningful ways. If conflicts persist, family therapy or grief counseling can provide neutral facilitation.

What if I can't afford the memorial option that feels most meaningful?

Loving someone deeply doesn't require spending beyond your financial means. Your loved one would likely want you to make financially responsible choices that don't create additional stress during grief. Consider memorial approaches that offer meaning through experience and connection rather than high cost. Many meaningful memorial experiences cost very little but provide lasting comfort and connection.

How do I know if I'm choosing a memorial for the right reasons?

Examine whether your decision is based on honoring your loved one's authentic values and supporting your family's healing, or whether external pressures are influencing your choice. Ask yourself: What would I choose if I knew no one else would judge my decision? Am I choosing based on what others will think or what will truly honor my loved one? Quality memorial decisions feel peaceful and aligned with your family's genuine needs.

What if I regret my memorial decision later?

Memorial regret often stems from rushed decisions made during intense grief rather than thoughtful choices made when ready. Taking time for reflection and values clarification significantly reduces the likelihood of future regret. If you do have concerns about a memorial choice later, remember that additional memorial experiences can always be created. Your connection with your loved one exists independently of any specific memorial choice.

About the Editor

Cathy Sanchez Babao

Cathy Sanchez Babao is a Grief Coach at Parting Stone, a grief educator, counselor, author, and columnist who has dedicated her career to helping individuals and families navigate loss. She writes the “Roots and Wings” column for the Philippine Daily Inquirer and is the author of Heaven’s Butterfly and Between Loss and Forever: Filipina Mothers on the Grief Journey. Cathy holds a B.S. in Business Administration and Management from Ateneo de Manila University and an M.A. in Family Psychology and Education from Miriam College, with advanced grief training at the Center for Loss & Life Transition and the Center for Prolonged Grief at Columbia University.

References

Cohen, J. S. (2022, August 16). Avoid major decision-making while grieving—Why this is important. Jill Grief Counselor. https://www.jillgriefcounselor.com/blog/avoid-decision-making-while-grieving

Jose, S. (2020). Progressing through grief: Guided exercises to understand your emotions and recover from loss. PESI Publishing.

Myers, S., & Donley, A. (2022). Digital memorialization and continuing bonds in the digital age. Death Studies, 46(8), 1824-1835.

Porter, S. (2023). Grief counseling through therapeutic questioning. Counselling Connection. https://www.counsellingconnection.com/index.php/2010/03/16/grief-counselling-through-questioning/

Robinson, K., & Pond, R. (2019). Online grief counseling: Accessibility and effectiveness in digital therapy. Journal of Digital Health, 5(2), 112-126.

Soulistic Hospice. (2024). Common questions to ask your grief counselor. Soulistic Hospice Blog. https://soulistichospice.org/blog/common-questions-to-ask-your-grief-counselor

University of Illinois at Chicago Counseling Center. (2020). Grief journaling prompts. https://counseling.uic.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/329/2020/05/Grief-Journaling-Prompts.pdf

VITAS Healthcare. (2023). Specific questions, techniques can help the bereaved cope with loss. https://www.vitas.com/family-and-caregiver-support/grief-and-bereavement/grief-support/techniques-used-to-assist-the-bereaved

Wolfelt, A. D. (2016). Understanding your grief: Ten essential touchstones for finding hope and healing your heart. Companion Press.

Worden, J. W. (2018). Grief counseling and grief therapy: A handbook for the mental health practitioner (5th ed.). Springer Publishing Company.