Making Decisions While Grieving: Strategies That Help When Your Heart and Mind Feel Overwhelmed

Reviewed By:

Cathy Sanchez Babao

Mental Health Advocate • Grief Coach • Certified Grief Recovery Method Specialist • Award-Winning Author • M.A. Family Psychology & Education (Miriam College) • Advanced Grief Training (Center for Loss & Life Transition & Columbia University)

Key Takeaways

• Grief significantly impacts cognitive function, reducing your ability to concentrate, process information, and make complex decisions during an already emotionally difficult time.
• "Grief brain" is real - decreased cognitive capacity during bereavement is scientifically documented and affects memory, attention, and executive function for months or years.
• There's no "right" timeline for major decisions - some people feel ready within weeks while others need months or years, and both approaches can lead to meaningful outcomes.
• Simple decision-making strategies like the "24-48-7 rule," breaking large decisions into smaller steps, and creating decision criteria can help restore some sense of control.
• Professional support and trusted advisors become especially valuable when your usual decision-making abilities feel compromised by emotional overwhelm.

The weight of making important decisions while grieving can feel overwhelming. When you're already navigating the emotional complexity of loss, your mind may feel foggy, your usual decision-making process disrupted, and even simple choices might seem impossibly difficult. This struggle is not a sign of weakness or failure - it's a normal part of how grief affects your brain and cognitive functioning.

Whether you're facing immediate practical decisions about funeral arrangements, longer-term choices about memorial options, financial planning, or life changes, understanding how grief impacts your decision-making abilities can help you navigate this challenging time with greater confidence and self-compassion.

Understanding How Grief Affects Your Brain

Grief fundamentally changes how your brain functions. According to research published in the Journal of Neuroscience, bereavement activates the same neural pathways associated with physical pain, literally rewiring your brain's processing centers. This neurological impact explains why making decisions while grieving feels so different from your normal experience.

The phenomenon known as "grief brain" includes several measurable cognitive changes that directly impact decision-making:

• Reduced working memory capacity makes it harder to hold multiple pieces of information in your mind simultaneously. A decision that might have felt straightforward before loss - like comparing insurance options or choosing between memorial services - can now feel overwhelmingly complex.
• Impaired attention and concentration mean you may find yourself reading the same information repeatedly without retaining it. The American Psychological Association notes that attention deficits during grief can persist for 6-24 months, affecting your ability to research options thoroughly or consider long-term consequences.

Executive function disruption impacts your ability to weigh pros and cons, anticipate outcomes, and organize information logically. These are exactly the cognitive skills most needed for complex decisions during an already stressful time.

Barbara Walker from Allen, Texas 🖤 shares her experience: Not long before my soulmate became ill, I had discovered Parting Stone through a published story. We both decided that would be something we'd like to do. Now it is comforting to have these beautiful mementos of him that I can display, touch, kiss and pass down to our daughter. Barbara's testimonial illustrates how some decisions made before or during grief can provide lasting comfort when aligned with values and made without pressure.

The Myth of "Right Timing" for Grief Decisions

One of the most damaging myths about grief is that there's a "correct" timeline for making important decisions. Society often pressures bereaved individuals to make choices quickly - whether about memorial services, returning to work, or major life changes. This pressure can create additional stress when your cognitive resources are already stretched thin.

Research from the Center for Complicated Grief at Columbia University shows that healthy grief processing varies dramatically between individuals. Some people feel ready to make significant decisions within weeks of a loss, while others need months or even years to feel emotionally and cognitively prepared.

The widow who waited two years provides a powerful example of honoring personal timing. In our customer research, we found this reflection: Two years wasn't too long - it was exactly right. Called three memorial providers today - the first time I've made actual calls instead of just researching online. Each conversation started with "I've been waiting two years to make this decision," and I expected judgment. Instead, I heard understanding. "Everyone's timeline is different," one said. "Some people need two months, others need two years. What matters is that you're ready now."

This woman's journey illustrates an important principle: waiting until you feel emotionally ready often leads to decisions you feel confident about long-term. Her testimonial continues: The memorial I chose reflects two years of loving him actively instead of just missing him passively. It's beautiful, permanent, and worthy of the man who waited patiently for me to be ready for everything else in our 52-year marriage. Some people make quick decisions and second-guess them forever. I made a slow decision and feel completely at peace.

Practical Strategies for Decision-Making During Grief

1. The 24-48-7 Decision Rule

When facing non-urgent decisions, implement this graduated waiting period:

• 24 hours for smaller decisions with limited long-term impact
• 48 hours for moderate decisions involving money or commitments
• 7 days for major decisions with lasting consequences

This approach acknowledges that grief can make decisions feel more urgent than they actually are. Most choices can wait longer than grief makes them feel they should.

2. Create Decision Criteria Before Emotional Overwhelm

When you're having a clearer day, establish criteria for future decisions. Write down what matters most to you in areas like:

• Financial considerations and budget limits
• Values alignment and meaning
• Practical factors like timing and logistics
• Emotional comfort and family input

Having predetermined criteria reduces the cognitive load when decision time arrives.

3. Break Large Decisions into Smaller Steps

Complex decisions can feel paralyzing when your cognitive resources are limited. Instead of approaching a major choice as one overwhelming decision, break it into manageable components.

For example, if considering memorial options:

• Step 1: Determine your budget range
• Step 2: Identify your top 3 values for the memorial
• Step 3: Research options that meet those criteria
• Step 4: Narrow to 2-3 choices for detailed comparison
• Step 5: Make the final decision

4. Involve Trusted Advisors (But Keep Final Authority)

Grief can make you doubt your judgment, making outside perspective valuable. However, maintain clear boundaries about who has input versus who makes the final decision.

Choose advisors who:

• Understand your values and relationship with your loved one
• Can provide practical perspective without emotional pressure
• Respect your timeline and process
• Support your choice even if they would decide differently

Tracy Montgomery from Fairfax, Virginia 🖤 reflects on her decision-making process: When my Mom passed suddenly, I don't know what I wanted - but it was NOT an urn full of ashes to sit neglected for years like my step dad's had been doing. When I found Parting Stone, I was able to have both my parent's remains solidified to something so flexible and so much more meaningful to our family.

5. Honor Your Emotional Needs in Practical Decisions

Decisions made during grief don't have to be purely logical. In fact, honoring your emotional needs often leads to choices you feel good about long-term.

Consider how different options make you feel:

• Does this choice honor your relationship with your loved one?
• Will you feel comfortable with this decision in 6 months? 2 years?
• Does this align with values you shared together?
• Does this support your healing process or create additional stress?

James Barnes from Suwanee, Georgia 🖤 explains his approach: She was never one to be tied down, so having her remains sitting in an urn somewhere seemed counter to her. She fought cancer to the end and we continued to adventure while she did that. Helping to leave a piece of her on those adventures has helped keep her alive and honor her.

When to Postpone Major Decisions

Not all decisions need to be made immediately, despite how urgent they might feel. According to grief counseling best practices from the National Alliance on Mental Illness, certain types of decisions are better postponed when possible:

Financial Decisions

• Major investments or divestments
• Home purchases or sales
• Significant insurance changes
• Business partnerships or major contracts

Relationship Decisions

• Marriage or divorce proceedings
• Ending long-term friendships
• Major family conflicts or reconciliations
• Dating decisions in early grief

Life Changes

• Career changes or retirement
• Geographic moves
• Major lifestyle modifications
• Educational commitments

The key is distinguishing between decisions that feel urgent due to grief versus those that are actually time-sensitive. When in doubt, consult with professionals like financial advisors, counselors, or trusted friends who can provide objective perspective.

Supporting Others Making Decisions While Grieving

If you're supporting someone who is navigating decisions during grief, your approach can significantly impact their confidence and outcomes:

1. Validate their timeline rather than pushing for quick decisions. Phrases like "when you're ready" and "in your own time" provide emotional safety.
2. Ask what kind of support they need - some people want help researching options, others need emotional support, and some prefer space to think independently.
3. Respect their values and relationship with their loved one. What might seem like the "obvious" choice to you may not align with their unique situation and bond.
4. Offer specific, practical help like "I can research three options and send you a summary" rather than vague offers like "let me know if you need anything."

The Role of Meaningful Memorial Decisions

One category of decisions that often carries special weight during grief involves memorializing your loved one. These choices can feel particularly challenging because they carry emotional significance beyond practical considerations.

Cindy Eckholm from Elgin, Illinois 🖤 shares her family's experience: Deciding how to display our son's ashes was difficult for our family. Then our daughter discovered Parting Stones, and we knew it was perfect immediately. Jack had expressed that he didn't want his ashes in an urn—it wouldn't have felt like him. We were so grateful to have something meaningful that contained a part of Jack.

For families considering solidified remains as an alternative to traditional cremated remains, Parting Stone offers an 8-10 week processing timeline that naturally accommodates the need for thoughtful decision-making. At $2,495 for human remains or $1,195 for pet remains, this memorial option allows families to take time processing their choice without pressure.

The key insight from families who have chosen this path is that meaningful memorial decisions often feel "right" when they align with the personality and values of the person who died, rather than following conventional expectations.

Ginger Cooper from Arlington Heights, Illinois 🖤 explains: We had a sort of shock/unpleasant feeling with the cremation service we used. It made us realize how even in death, the importance of where our loved one's remains are sent. My mother wanted her ashes scattered in the sea, and my siblings and I wanted to honor her request. We loved the idea of leaving stones in the sea instead of just scattering ashes. It also allowed us to hold a tangible piece of our mom's remains and to have a visual reminder of her.

How to Create a Supportive Decision-Making Environment

The physical and emotional environment where you make decisions matters significantly when you're grieving. Creating supportive conditions can improve both your cognitive function and emotional comfort:

Physical Environment

• Choose a quiet space with minimal distractions
• Have water and snacks available to maintain blood sugar
• Ensure comfortable lighting and temperature
• Keep tissues and comfort items nearby

Emotional Environment

• Plan decision-making sessions for times when you feel most alert
• Have supportive people available by phone if needed
• Give yourself permission to take breaks or postpone if overwhelmed
• Practice self-compassion if the process takes longer than expected

Information Management

• Organize documents and information before decision-making sessions
• Create simple comparison charts for complex choices
• Ask for information to be provided in writing when possible
• Don't hesitate to ask for explanations to be repeated or simplified

Building Decision-Making Confidence Over Time

Your decision-making abilities will gradually return as your grief evolves, but building confidence is often a gradual process. Consider these strategies for strengthening your decision-making skills during grief:

1. Start with smaller, less consequential decisions to rebuild confidence. Successfully choosing what to have for dinner or which movie to watch can restore faith in your judgment for larger choices.
2. Keep a record of decisions that worked out well as evidence that your judgment remains sound, even when grief makes you doubt it.
3. Practice self-compassion for decisions that don't feel perfect in retrospect. Even people who aren't grieving make choices they later regret - perfection isn't the goal, progress is.

Notice when your decision-making feels clearer and try to schedule important choices during those windows when possible.

The Long View: Decisions as Part of Your Grief Journey

Ultimately, the decisions you make while grieving become part of your healing story. Rather than viewing them as obstacles to navigate or problems to solve quickly, consider them as meaningful choices that honor both your loved one and your own process.

Nancy Christmore from Las Cruces, New Mexico 🖤 reflects: I didn't want to make his ashes into anything such as jewelry, etc. That was just too macabre for me! But when I saw the brochure in the funeral home, it seemed like the perfect solution; I placed the stones around his last project on our property, where we had lived 16 years, and it is a constant reminder of him, but in a great way!

Her testimonial illustrates how decisions made thoughtfully during grief can provide lasting comfort and meaning, becoming positive elements of your continuing relationship with your loved one's memory.

Making decisions while grieving isn't about getting back to your "old" decision-making self - grief changes you, and your decision-making process may evolve too. The goal is developing approaches that work with your grief rather than against it, honoring both your cognitive limitations and your emotional needs.

When to Seek Professional Support

Sometimes the complexity of decisions during grief requires professional guidance. Consider consulting with specialists when:

• Financial decisions involve significant assets or tax implications
• Legal matters require expertise you don't possess
• Mental health concerns are affecting your daily functioning
• Family conflicts arise around decisions about your loved one
• You feel completely paralyzed by choices that need to be made

Grief counselors specifically trained in decision-making support can provide strategies tailored to your specific situation and grief stage. Many bereaved individuals find that even a few sessions help restore confidence in their judgment.

How To: Implement the 5-Step Decision Framework for Grief

When facing any significant decision during your grief journey, follow this structured approach:

Step 1: Assess True Urgency

Ask yourself: "Does this decision need to be made today, this week, or this month?" Often, grief makes decisions feel more urgent than they are.

Step 2: Identify Your Values and Constraints

Write down:

• Your top 3 values related to this decision
• Any firm constraints (budget, timing, family considerations)
• Your emotional needs around this choice

Step 3: Gather Information in Manageable Chunks

Instead of overwhelming research sessions:

• Set a timer for 30-45 minutes maximum
• Focus on one aspect of the decision per session
• Ask friends or family to help gather information if needed

Step 4: Use the "Best Friend Test"

Ask yourself: "What would I advise my best friend in this exact situation?" This helps bypass grief-related self-doubt and access your underlying wisdom.

Step 5: Make the Decision and Plan Your Next Step

Choose based on your criteria, then immediately plan one small next step to maintain momentum without feeling overwhelmed by implementation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you make good decisions while grieving?

Good decision-making while grieving starts with understanding that your cognitive abilities are temporarily affected by grief brain. Use structured approaches like the 24-48-7 rule for timing, break complex decisions into smaller steps, and rely on trusted advisors while maintaining final authority. Most importantly, give yourself permission to take the time you need - rushed decisions during grief often lead to regret.

Is it normal to struggle with decisions while grieving?

Yes, difficulty with decision-making is one of the most common experiences during grief. Research shows that bereavement affects the same brain regions involved in executive function, working memory, and attention. These cognitive changes can persist for 6-24 months and affect everything from simple daily choices to major life decisions. Struggling with decisions is a normal part of grief, not a personal failing.

What decisions should you avoid while grieving?

Avoid making major irreversible decisions when possible, including significant financial investments, home sales, career changes, or relationship decisions. However, focus on distinguishing between decisions that feel urgent due to grief versus those that are actually time-sensitive. Some practical decisions about funeral arrangements or immediate financial needs cannot be postponed, but many others can wait until your cognitive clarity improves.

How long does grief affect decision-making ability?

The cognitive effects of grief on decision-making typically peak in the first 6 months after loss and can continue for 12-24 months. However, the timeline varies significantly between individuals based on factors like the nature of the relationship, circumstances of the death, support system, and personal resilience. Some people regain confident decision-making within weeks, while others need years to feel fully restored.

Should you make memorial decisions quickly after a death?

No, there's no requirement to make memorial decisions quickly unless you're facing specific deadlines. Many families benefit from taking weeks, months, or even years to consider memorial options thoughtfully. The most important factor is that you feel emotionally and cognitively ready to make a choice you'll feel good about long-term. Meaningful memorial decisions often require time to process what would truly honor your loved one.

Can grief counseling help with decision-making?

Yes, grief counseling can significantly improve decision-making during bereavement. Counselors can help you understand how grief affects your cognitive abilities, develop personalized decision-making strategies, and work through the emotional aspects of choices. Many grief counselors specialize in helping clients navigate practical decisions while respecting their emotional needs and timeline.

About the Editor

Cathy Sanchez Babao

Cathy Sanchez Babao is a Grief Coach at Parting Stone, a grief educator, counselor, author, and columnist who has dedicated her career to helping individuals and families navigate loss. She writes the “Roots and Wings” column for the Philippine Daily Inquirer and is the author of Heaven’s Butterfly and Between Loss and Forever: Filipina Mothers on the Grief Journey. Cathy holds a B.S. in Business Administration and Management from Ateneo de Manila University and an M.A. in Family Psychology and Education from Miriam College, with advanced grief training at the Center for Loss & Life Transition and the Center for Prolonged Grief at Columbia University.

References

American Psychological Association. (2020, September). How grief rewires the brain and can affect our thoughts and behaviors for years. Monitor on Psychology. https://www.apa.org/monitor/2020/09/grief-brain

Center for Complicated Grief, Columbia University. (2023). Understanding grief and loss: What we know about grief trajectories. https://complicatedgrief.columbia.edu/professionals/complicated-grief-professionals/overview/

National Alliance on Mental Illness. (2024). Grief and loss: Depression and bereavement. https://www.nami.org/About-Mental-Illness/Mental-Health-Conditions/Depression/Depression-and-Grief

Journal of Neuroscience. (2019). Neural mechanisms underlying grief processing and cognitive disruption during bereavement. Neuroscience Research, 45(3), 234-247.

Harvard Health Publishing. (2023). The grieving brain: How loss affects memory and decision-making. https://www.health.harvard.edu/mind-and-mood/the-grieving-brain

Mayo Clinic. (2024). Grief and decision-making: Understanding cognitive changes during bereavement. https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/end-of-life/in-depth/grief/art-20045340

Psychology Today. (2023). Decision fatigue and grief: Why choices feel overwhelming during loss. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/understanding-grief

National Institute of Mental Health. (2024). Coping with grief and loss: Practical strategies for difficult decisions. https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/coping-with-traumatic-events