Continuing Bonds: What It Means to Stay Connected to Someone Who Died
Continuing bonds is the grief theory that staying connected to someone who died can be part of healthy grieving. What it means, what the research says, and when to check in.
Continuing bonds is a grief theory holding that people do not have to sever their emotional connection to someone who died in order to grieve well. The relationship changes form and goes on. Grief researchers Dennis Klass, Phyllis Silverman, and Steven Nickman introduced the idea in their 1996 book Continuing Bonds: New Understandings of Grief, challenging the long-held belief that the purpose of mourning is to let go.
You may already be living it. Maybe you still say goodnight to your mother, or you reach for the phone to tell your brother something before you remember. Maybe your father's reading glasses are still on the side table, or his cremated remains are on a shelf in the closet you open every morning. Continuing bonds is the name researchers gave to all of this, and the short version of what they found is that it is common, it is human, and for most people it is not a sign that grief has gone wrong.
Key points
- Continuing bonds describes grief as a relationship that changes rather than ends.
- The theory came from researchers who watched bereaved parents and children stay connected to the people they lost and remain psychologically healthy.
- Research is mixed on whether bonds help, and the clearest finding is that how a bond feels and functions matters more than whether one exists.
- A bond can live in words, rituals, values, places, and physical things, including a loved one's cremated remains.
What is continuing bonds?
Continuing bonds is the ongoing inner relationship a grieving person keeps with someone who has died. It includes talking to them, keeping their memory present in family life, carrying their values into new decisions, and holding onto objects and places connected to them. The theory treats these experiences as a normal part of grief rather than a failure to accept the death.
The shift the theory made is easiest to see side by side. The older view held that a person had grieved successfully once they had detached from the person who died and invested their love elsewhere. Continuing bonds holds that successful grieving often means finding a new, sustainable place for that person in your life. The relationship does not stay the same. A daughter who once called her mother every Sunday may now spend Sunday morning in her mother's garden. The bond has changed address, and it is still a bond.
Where did continuing bonds theory come from?
For most of the twentieth century, Western grief psychology followed a "letting go" model. It drew on Sigmund Freud's 1917 essay "Mourning and Melancholia," which described mourning as the slow work of withdrawing emotional attachment from the person who died so it could be reinvested in the living. Early applications of John Bowlby's attachment theory reinforced the same idea. Under this model, a grieving person who still spoke to or felt connected to the dead could be seen as stuck.
The people who challenged that model got there by listening. Beginning in 1979, Dennis Klass spent about ten years studying a St. Louis chapter of The Compassionate Friends, the self-help organization for bereaved parents, where he also served as professional advisor. He saw parents keep their children present in their homes, their conversations, and their sense of who they were, and those parents did not look unwell. Klass recalled facing a choice: either every parent in the group had pathological grief, or the definition of healthy grief was wrong. Phyllis Silverman, studying children whose parents had died, found the same pattern. Children kept an inner relationship with the parent and revised it as they grew.
In 1996, Klass, Silverman, and Steven Nickman published Continuing Bonds: New Understandings of Grief, an edited volume with 22 contributing authors drawing on research with bereaved parents, children, and spouses, and with cultures outside the West, including a chapter by Klass on ancestor practices in Japan. The book argued that the healthy resolution of grief can include a continuing bond with the person who died, and it reshaped how bereavement professionals talk about grief.
What does a continuing bond look like in everyday life?
Continuing bonds show up in ordinary, specific moments. Researchers group them in a few broad ways, and most people recognize themselves in more than one.
In words. Talking to the person who died, out loud in the car or silently at the kitchen sink. Writing them letters on their birthday. Telling a grandchild the story about the time Grandpa drove the wrong way to the Grand Canyon and refused to admit it.
In rituals. Making her lasagna every Christmas Eve because she did. Lighting a candle on the anniversary. Families often build these on purpose; our guide to anniversary memorial traditions has ideas.
In values and guidance. Asking "what would Dad say?" before a big decision. Becoming more patient because that is what she would have wanted. Researchers call this an internalized bond: the person becomes part of how you think and choose.
In places and things. Wearing his watch. Keeping her voicemail. Visiting the bench at the lake. Keeping a loved one's cremated remains at home, or carrying a small portion of them somewhere they always wanted to go.
In a sense of presence. Feeling that they are nearby, noticing a cardinal on the fence, catching their cologne in a crowded room. Researchers call these externalized bonds because the connection is experienced as coming from outside.
Is continuing bonds healthy?
Continuing bonds is neither automatically healthy nor automatically unhealthy. Decades of research show that staying connected to someone who died is common and often comforting, but studies disagree on whether stronger bonds lead to better adjustment. The clearest finding is that the kind of bond and how it feels matter more than whether a bond exists.
The evidence, fairly summarized:
- A 2005 review by Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut concluded that neither continuing nor relinquishing bonds can be called generally helpful, and that the real question is how, and for whom, each helps.
- A five-year study of widows and widowers by Nigel Field, Eval Gal-Oz, and George Bonanno found that people with stronger bonds reported more grief-specific symptoms over the five years. Stronger bonds were also linked to having had a more satisfying marriage, which is a reminder that a strong bond often reflects a strong relationship.
- A 2023 systematic review in Death Studies by Helen Hewson and colleagues pulled together 79 studies covering about 13,400 bereaved people. It found that continuing bonds bring comfort to most people, usually alongside sadness, because the bond makes both the person's presence and their absence felt. It also found that, in some studies, keeping possessions was associated with more intense grief than drawing on memories.
Internalized vs. externalized bonds
Researchers distinguish two kinds of continuing bonds. An internalized bond is a connection carried inside: the person's values, voice, and example act as a steady inner guide. An externalized bond is a connection experienced as outside you, such as sensing the person in the room or briefly seeing or hearing them.
In a study of 502 bereaved adults, Nigel Field and Charles Filanosky found that externalized bonds were associated with violent deaths and with feeling responsible for the death. Other research points the same way: a study of 354 bereaved parents found that internalized bonds were linked to a more positive grief status and externalized bonds to the opposite, and the 2023 Hewson review found internalized bonds linked to personal growth in several studies. Externalized experiences are common and not a cause for alarm on their own. When they feel frightening or constant, they are worth mentioning to a grief counselor.
How to tell whether your bond is helping
No questionnaire replaces a conversation with a professional, but the research suggests a few honest questions:
- After time with the bond (a conversation at the grave, an hour with old photos, holding something of theirs), do you usually feel steadier, or more shaken?
- Is this something you choose and can set down, or something you feel unable to stop?
- Does the bond sit alongside the rest of your life, including work, sleep, and other people, or does it crowd those out?
If the answers lean toward comfort, choice, and room for the rest of your life, the bond is likely doing what bonds tend to do. If they lean the other way, that is worth taking seriously and worth bringing to someone trained in grief.
When grief needs more support
A long-lasting bond is not a disorder. In 2022 the American Psychiatric Association added prolonged grief disorder to the DSM-5-TR. For adults, a diagnosis requires that at least 12 months have passed since the death, that intense yearning for the person or preoccupation with them has been present nearly every day for at least the last month, and that the grief causes significant distress or disrupts work, relationships, or daily life. What defines the disorder is that level of disabling distress, not the presence of a connection. If that description fits, a grief counselor or therapist trained in grief can help, and our guide to why grief returns around anniversaries explains a pattern many people mistake for going backward.
What if you don't feel a bond?
Continuing bonds describes what many grieving people experience. It is not a requirement. Some people feel little ongoing connection and are grieving in a perfectly healthy way. Others had a relationship marked by conflict, distance, or harm, and a "bond" is the last thing they want. The Hewson review found that bonds were more likely to bring distress when the relationship before the death involved conflict, dependency, or unfinished business. Grief for a complicated relationship can be complicated too, and that is not a failure.
How does continuing bonds fit with the five stages and other grief models?
Continuing bonds answers a different question than the five stages of grief. The five stages, popularized by Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, describe emotional reactions a person may move through. Continuing bonds describes what happens to the relationship itself.
It fits most naturally with the Dual Process Model of coping with bereavement, published by Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut in 1999. That model describes healthy grieving as moving back and forth between facing the loss (missing the person, looking at photos, crying at their favorite song) and rebuilding daily life (new routines, new roles, time with other people). A continuing bond often lives on the loss side of that rhythm. The model's point is that both sides matter, and that time spent connecting with the person who died is part of grieving, as long as there is also room to live.
What role can cremated remains play in a continuing bond?
For families who chose cremation, the cremated remains are often the most literal link to the person who died. Parting Stone's Ash Storage Reckoning study surveyed 1,000 U.S. adults who had received a loved one's cremated remains. Sixty-six percent said they often or always feel a connection to their loved one, and 59 percent said they often or always feel comfort from having them nearby.
The same study found that 76 percent have not yet carried out a final plan for the remains. Both findings can be true for the same person: the remains are a real source of closeness, and they are also a decision that has quietly waited for years. When a box sits in the back of a closet, it can feel less like presence and more like a question nobody has answered.
The research on possessions points to a useful way to think about this. What matters is less which choice a family makes and more whether the arrangement supports the bond they have. A few questions help, whatever a family is considering:
- Does where the remains are now feel like they are with you, or like they are waiting?
- Do several people need to feel close to this person, perhaps in different homes or states?
- Would you want to be able to hold something of them, or bring them somewhere meaningful?
Families answer these in different ways, and many answers are good ones. An urn on the mantel can be the heart of a home. Scattering at a favorite lake can be the ritual a family returns to every year. Burial gives grandchildren a place to visit. For more on the full range, see our guide to what to do with cremated remains.
Some families find they want the bond to have a form they can hold in their hand and share among everyone who loved the person. Solidified remains were made for that. Parting Stone has said publicly that the idea for solidified remains was inspired by continuing bonds theory. Through a patented process Parting Stone pioneered, virtually all of a person's cremated remains are transformed into a collection of 40 to 80+ smooth, solid stones. A daughter can carry one in her coat pocket. Siblings in three states can each display a few at home. A family can place one at the trailhead where their father hiked every summer and scatter others where he asked. More than 15,000 families have chosen solidified remains.
A stone does not create a bond, and it does not make grief shorter. What it can do is give a bond that already exists a form that is comfortable to touch, easy to share, and present in everyday life.
How can you tend a continuing bond?
There is no right method, and the best rituals tend to come from the specific person rather than a list. A few that families often describe: writing to the person on dates that mattered; cooking their recipes with the people who loved them; keeping one object somewhere you will see it daily rather than everything somewhere you will not; telling the stories that only you remember so the next generation knows them; and bringing something of them to the places they loved or never got to see.
If any of these brings more pain than comfort right now, set it down and try again later, or not at all. Grief researchers describe healthy grieving as a rhythm of turning toward the loss and turning toward life. A bond can be part of that rhythm without being all of it.
Frequently asked questions about continuing bonds
Who created continuing bonds theory? Continuing bonds theory was introduced by Dennis Klass, Phyllis Silverman, and Steven Nickman in their 1996 edited book Continuing Bonds: New Understandings of Grief. Klass's research with bereaved parents in The Compassionate Friends and Silverman's research with bereaved children were central to the theory.
Is it normal to talk to someone who has died? Talking to someone who has died is common and is one of the most frequent ways people continue their bond. Grief researchers consider it a normal part of grieving. It becomes a concern only if it comes with persistent, disabling distress.
What is the difference between internalized and externalized continuing bonds? An internalized continuing bond is a connection carried inside, where the person's values and memory guide your thinking. An externalized continuing bond is experienced as outside you, such as sensing, seeing, or hearing the person. Research links internalized bonds more often with a positive grief course and personal growth, and externalized bonds more often with difficult grief, especially after violent deaths.
Can continuing bonds be unhealthy? Continuing bonds can be unhealthy when they bring more distress than comfort, feel compulsive, or crowd out daily life. Research does not show that having a bond is harmful in itself. Persistent, disabling yearning for 12 months or more may indicate prolonged grief disorder, which a grief professional can assess and treat.
Do you have to feel a continuing bond to grieve well? No. Continuing bonds describes a common experience, not a requirement. Many people grieve in healthy ways without feeling an ongoing connection, especially after a complicated or painful relationship.
Is it okay to keep a loved one's cremated remains at home? Keeping cremated remains at home is generally legal in the United States, and it is a common choice. Many families say having their loved one nearby brings comfort. Whether it supports your grief depends on whether the arrangement feels like connection or like an unmade decision.
A bond that fits your life
The researchers who named continuing bonds did not invent a new way to grieve. They noticed what bereaved parents, widows, and children had been doing all along and stopped calling it a problem. If you are still talking to someone you lost, you are in very good company.
If you are curious what it would look like to hold that connection in your hand, you can see how solidified remains are made, in your own time.